Jennifer Love Hewitt has lastly spilled the tea on her alleged decades-long feud with Sarah Michelle Gellar, and spoiler alert: there isn’t one! The plot twist? They haven’t really spoken since their orginal I Know What You Did Final Summer time days again in 1997.
In a candid chat with Vulture, Hewitt, now 46, dismissed the web drama surrounding her supposed beef with Gellar, 48. Discuss a ghost story – these two haven’t crossed paths since Hewitt was rocking her teenage years when their slasher hit first terrorized audiences.
“I actually don’t even know what that was or how that each one got here to be,” Hewitt mentioned in regards to the rumored stress, in all probability questioning why the web loves drama greater than a teen horror film.
“I simply suppose individuals don’t need the narrative to be simple,” she mused. “Why will we all the time should be towards one another and out for one another?”
“I haven’t seen Sarah,” the Social gathering of 5 alum continued, setting the file straight. “Actually, we’ve not talked since I noticed her at 18 years previous when the primary film got here out. That’s why it’s so humorous to me. Folks had been like, ‘Say one thing again.’ And I’m like, ‘What am I going to say? I’ve not seen her.’ On my aspect, we’re good. I don’t know the place that is coming from.”
Hewitt, who performed the screaming queen Julie James within the unique I Know What You Did Final Summer time, has stored the franchise alive by returning for each the 1998 sequel and, surprisingly, the newest installment launched Friday. Discuss dedication to operating from fictional killers!
Gellar’s hubby, Freddie Prinze Jr., who performed Julie’s love curiosity Ray Bronson, can also be again for extra summer time scares within the 2025 sequel. Clearly, some individuals simply can’t get sufficient of being chased by mysterious hook-wielding figures.
Whereas each Gellar and Ryan Phillipe sat out the sequels (their characters Helen and Barry obtained the everlasting form of exit within the unique), Gellar did pop up in a dream sequence within the newest film. And in a plot twist worthy of the franchise itself, The Ghost Whisperer star joined Prinze Jr. on the premiere, which Hewitt additionally attended. Possibly they lastly had that long-overdue chat?
Neither star appeared within the 2006 direct-to-video sequel (in all probability for the most effective) or the short-lived 2022 TV collection. However hey, not less than we obtained this scrumptious slice of ’90s nostalgia served contemporary in 2025!
Through the pre-premiere buzz, Vulture caught up with Hewitt and popped the million-dollar query: Would she be crossing paths with Gellar on the occasion?
“I hope so,” Hewitt replied, holding it quick and candy.
Publish-premiere, eagle-eyed followers seen one thing fishy – no purple carpet images of the 2 stars collectively surfaced. When followers began enjoying detective on social media in regards to the alleged feud, Gellar stepped in to clear the air with some basic mom-life realness.
“For all you curious cats on the market – nope, didn’t get to see @jenniferlovehewitt who completely kills it within the film,” Gellar defined on Instagram. “Mother obligation referred to as, and I used to be inside with my kiddos throughout the massive purple carpet second. JLH couldn’t make it to the after-party both.
“And let’s be actual about these occasions – they’re pure chaos!” she added. “Sadly missed photograph ops with many of the forged. However that doesn’t change how unbelievable I feel all of them are. Some magic moments simply occur IRL and never for the ‘gram.”
The rumor mill kicked into overdrive again in December 2024 when an “Further” reporter tried to get the inside track from Gellar about Hewitt’s potential comeback for the 2025 flick.
“I’ve nothing to do with that,” Gellar responded, making a swift exit that may make any horror film survivor proud.
Later, Gellar took to Instagram Tales to clarify her cryptic response, blaming it on her battle with these pesky NDAs (Non-Disclosure Agreements) about casting reveals.
“Aspiring actors, take observe: This ‘deer in headlights’ look is ideal whenever you’re stoked to see previous friends in a venture however forgot what NDA stands for… once more this month,” she quipped alongside a behind-the-scenes snap.
That very same month, Hewitt confirmed her return to the franchise with an Instagram put up that had followers screaming (with pleasure this time).
The plot thickened in April when Gellar shared the 2025 I Know What You Did Final Summer time trailer, tagging everybody from Prinze Jr. to newcomers Madelyn Cline and Chase Sui Wonders, plus the inventive workforce – however mysteriously leaving out Hewitt.
Be a part of the SL Neighborhood
Have an opinion on what you simply learn? Signal as much as be part of the Socialite Life neighborhood as a way to put up a remark, bookmark your favourite articles, matters, and contributors.
